Team YifeiTeam YifeiRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., BrokerageAsk Yifei · Real Estate Q&A中文

Should you renovate your house before selling in Niagara?

Here is my honest take: many sellers think a renovation before listing will bring a higher price, but in Niagara a big renovation rarely pays for itself. Fix what is broken, and do not spend big on making it pretty. Buyers price your home off what nearby homes sold for, not off what you spent. A great renovation adds little, while broken things get you beaten down on price. I am talking to owners who are about to sell and are tempted to renovate first. It only makes sense when the homes that sold around you were all updated, yours clearly lags behind, and the numbers show you will get back more than you spend.
The 1 minute version
1 / 9
Ask Yifei · Selling
01
Should you renovate before selling in Niagara?
$200K
lost on one full renovation

Swipe for the 1 minute answer

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 1/9
Yifei's take
02
Fix what's broken. Skip the pretty stuff.

Buyers price off what sold nearby, not what you spent. A great reno adds little, while broken things get you beaten down.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 2/9
A real Niagara sale
03
$300K+
Gutted and redone, then lost about $200K

Windows, kitchen, floors, all new. Renovating to your own taste is for you. Buyers pay what the neighbourhood supports.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 3/9
Why it rarely pays
04
Buyers rarely pay extra for what no neighbour has
  • 01Buyers only compare nearby sales
  • 02Basement reno: tens of thousands, same price
  • 03A month or two of work, prices can slip
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 4/9
Draw two columns
05
Fix it or skip it
01Fix: doors, lightsAnything that won't close or turn on
02Fix: cracks, leaksGouged cabinets, cracked glass, leaks
03Skip: big jobsNew kitchen, basement, flooring
04Skip: extrasFeatures no home nearby has
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 5/9
What sells it instead
06
Spend little. Clean and stage.
  • 01Deep clean and clear the clutter
  • 02Take down decals, use plain bedding
  • 03Keep decor neutral
  • 04Stage where you can
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 6/9
Before you build
07
Touching structure or wiring? Ask the city

In Ontario, building permits go through your municipality. Its building department can tell you if you need one. Asking costs nothing.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 7/9
When it does make sense
08
Every sold home nearby is updated but yours

If the extra sale price beats the cost, go ahead. Money can buy a renovation, not the street you live on.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 8/9
Your own house
09
Thinking of renovating first?

Tell Yifei what your home looks like now and what you want to change. He will help you run the numbers.

Ask Yifei
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 9/9

Why big renovations rarely pay off

I sold a house in Niagara where the owner had paid a little over $700,000, then gutted it, replacing windows, kitchen and floors, for over $300,000. It was meant to be their own home. When it came time to sell, they had a little over $1 million in it and it sold for just over $800,000. That is roughly $200,000 lost. Renovating to your own taste is for living in, not for the buyer, and buyers only pay what the neighbourhood supports.

Another seller wanted to finish the basement first. I ran the numbers: a few tens of thousands of dollars, a month or two of work, and the sale price would be about the same as today. Another seller with a home worth over a million wanted to spend tens of thousands on the basement and kitchen. My math said the extra sale price would not cover the cost, so they skipped it.

The logic is simple. If no home nearby has it, buyers rarely pay extra for it. And count the time: if prices slip during a month or two of work, any gain is gone.

一飞在尼亚加拉一套待售独立屋门前,跟卖家边走边指着外墙说话

How to split fix from skip

Draw two columns:

Broken, fix it
Doors that do not close, lights that do not work
Cosmetic, skip for nowA new kitchen
A gouged cabinet door, cracked glass
Cosmetic, skip for nowFinishing the basement
Missing outlet covers, leaks
Cosmetic, skip for nowNew flooring throughout
Appliances that do not work
Cosmetic, skip for nowFeatures no home nearby has

On one of my listings that is exactly what I decided: no renovation, just fix a door, fix a light, repair a cabinet door with a gouge, replace a pane of glass and put back the outlet covers. Even the painting waited. Cheap work, but buyers are less likely to walk in and spot problems.

For anything in the cosmetic column, check whether the homes that sold nearby had it. If they did not, leave it.

What sells the house instead

My approach is to spend little and rely on clean and staged, not renovated:

Ask the city before you build

If the work touches structure, plumbing or electrical, ask the municipality about permits first. I have seen a seller list soon after a renovation, with the basement described as having more than it used to. Within days the city called, and the listing had to come down until the permits were sorted out. In Ontario, building permit applications go to your municipality, and its building department can tell you whether your job needs one. Asking costs nothing.

When renovating does make sense

If every home that sold nearby has been updated and your kitchen has not been touched in decades, and the numbers show the extra sale price beats the cost, go ahead. Do the math first. Money can buy a renovation; it cannot buy the neighbourhood and the street you live on.

Tell me about your situation and I will tell you straight what to do (Yifei, RE/MAX, efay.ai).

Frequently asked questions

Is a fresh coat of paint worth it?

It depends on the walls. Dirty or dark walls are cheap to repaint in a light colour and look much cleaner. If the walls are in decent shape, you can skip it.

Do buyers lowball you if you skip the renovation?

Broken items will get you lowballed, so fix those first. For things that are dated but working, most buyers price off nearby sales rather than knocking off a big amount for no renovation.

出处 / Sources

Yifei on this topic (video in Mandarin)

卖房别瞎装修!这些小技巧,让你花小钱办大事! · YouTube 一飞说地产

Yifei Lin is a RE/MAX real estate agent serving the Greater Toronto Area and Niagara since 2015. For advice on your own situation, reach him at efay.ai.

All questions