Selling a home in Ontario: the buyer wants a price cut after the inspection. Should I agree?
Swipe for the 1 minute answer
Cutting by whatever number the buyer names is the most common seller mistake. Start with what the inspection actually found.
- 01The same issue can't be deducted twice
- 02Use your contractor's quote, not theirs
- 03Unsure about the clause? Ask a lawyer
Your agent should be there. Yifei's inspector walks the house with him and only talks to the client in the last 15 minutes.
- 01Get the full report and photos
- 02Have your own contractor quote
- 03Fix same day, send photos over
- 04Repair or credit? Lawyer writes it up
- 05Compare the cut to a collapsed deal
- 06Next time, inspect before you list
A cracked drain was replaced the same day. The deal later fell through, so Yifei sent the repair photos to the other agent. It sold again for over $600K.
Tell Yifei which items came up, whether they were already in the price, and if you have other buyers. He'll tell you straight what to do.
Ask YifeiWhy you shouldn't just accept the buyer's number
An inspection condition is one of the most common conditions in an Ontario offer. While the condition is open, a buyer who isn't satisfied with the report can come back to renegotiate, or may be able to get out of the deal depending on how the condition is written. That's the buyer's right, and you should plan for it. If you're unsure what the clause allows, have a real estate lawyer read it.
But an inspection report isn't a bill. Dated kitchens, worn floors and old windows were visible on day one and are already in the asking price. Yifei worked with sellers who had priced realistically from the start, having already lowered the price after looking at the market and an inspection report. When the buyer pushed for more off the report, Yifei pushed back: those issues are already in the price, and they can't be deducted twice.
When a buyer ignores what's already in the price, the cuts get unreasonable. In one negotiation Yifei pointed out that the seller had already left a large amount of renovation room in the price, and the buyer wanted roughly the same amount off again. That's charging the seller twice for the same thing, which isn't fair.
Which situation are you in
Whether you have other buyers, and how fast the market is moving, also shapes how much you give.
What to do
- Get the full report and photos, and ask exactly which items the buyer is negotiating on.
- Have your own contractor look and quote. If it can be fixed the same day, fix it, take photos and send them to the buyer's agent.
- Choose between repair and a price adjustment. Repairing puts the money where everyone can see it; adjusting the price means nobody else has to come into the house before closing. Have your lawyer confirm how the change is written into the agreement.
- If an engineer or contractor comes out, your agent should be there. Never let the expert negotiate price with the buyer directly. Yifei compares it to a home inspector, who walks the house with him and only talks to the client in the last 15 minutes.
- Do the math: compare the cut with the cost of the deal falling through. When a house comes back on the market after a collapsed deal, buyers wonder why.
- To avoid surprises, get your own pre-listing inspection so the issues are known and priced in before you list.
What Yifei has seen
A seller's detached house sold for a little over $600,000. The inspection found a cracked section of the main drain in the basement and a little mould in the attic. The seller's biggest worry was that this would kill the deal. The buyer was fine with it, and Yifei had a plumber replace the pipe that same day.
That deal later fell through over the buyer's financing, and the house went back on the market. The seller worried that buyers would now push the price down. The first thing Yifei did was put the issues on the table himself: photos of the new pipe went straight to the other agent, and he explained the bit of attic mould. As he put it, if you hide something and the buyer's inspection finds it, that's when it becomes a real problem. Never hide the inspection report, and send the repair bill over as soon as the work is finished. That is how Yifei has always sold homes at RE/MAX.
The second time it sold for a little over $600,000 again, about the same as the first time, and a bit more than the best offer in hand at that point.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to fix what the inspection found?
No. With an inspection condition, the buyer can negotiate, and may be able to walk away under the condition. Repair, credit or refuse is your call; just weigh the cost of losing the deal.
Should I fix it or give the buyer a credit?
Fix small items. For big ones, get a contractor's quote and adjust the price based on it, so both sides are working from the same number.
Ask about your own situation
Which items came up, whether they were already in the price, and whether you have other buyers decide how much to give. What did your report flag? Tell me about your situation and I'll tell you straight what to do (Yifei, RE/MAX, efay.ai).
Sources: - RECO, Home inspections: https://www.reco.on.ca/consumers/information-for-buyers/home-inspections/ - RECO, Buyer's checklist: https://www.reco.on.ca/consumers/information-for-buyers/buyers-checklist/
Yifei on this topic (video in Mandarin)
验房后买家在讲价怎么办? · YouTube 一飞说地产



