Team YifeiTeam YifeiRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., BrokerageAsk Yifei · Real Estate Q&A中文

Selling a home in Ontario: should I list low to get multiple offers, or list high and negotiate?

Here's my honest take: most sellers think listing high leaves room to negotiate, but what it really leaves you with is time on the market, and the longer a home sits, the weaker your position. The list price isn't the sale price; what you list at matters far less than what you sell for, so I price to the market, not above it. This is for Ontario sellers who are tempted to list high and see what happens; if your home is truly one of a kind, this doesn't apply to you. It's hard to get a bidding war right now: list high and buyers start negotiating from a low number, but price it right and one counter-offer usually gets the deal done. Listing low to draw multiple offers can work, but only for homes with lots of buyers and little competition, and you need to decide in advance that if nobody bids, you relist at market price right away.
The 1 minute version
1 / 9
Ask Yifei · Selling
01
List low for multiple offers, or list high and negotiate?
$700K
Listed here, first offer in the $500Ks

Swipe for the 1 minute answer

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 1/9
Yifei's take
02
Time
Listing high buys time, not room

List price is not sale price. What you sell for is what counts, and the longer a home sits, the weaker your position.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 2/9
The trouble with listing high
03
The number in your head is not the buyer's
  • 01Buyers searching your range never find you
  • 02The ones who come start low
  • 03More days on market, then a price cut
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 3/9
Yifei's example
04
$500Ks
First offer on a $700K listing

It ended up in the $600,000s, one step at a time.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 4/9
Three ways to price
05
For most homes, price to market
01List low, hold offersOnly with lots of buyers, few listings
02Price to marketRight for most homes, sells fast
03List high, negotiateRarely, unless truly one of a kind
04Nobody bids?Relist at market price right away
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 5/9
How to set it
06
4 steps to your list price
  • 01Check recent sales of similar homes nearby
  • 02Near a round number? List just under it
  • 03Going for offers? Set the offer date, relist price and bottom line first
  • 04First low offer: do not sign, do not reject. Counter.
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 6/9
Two Oakville listings
07
2,500 sq. ft.
The smaller home sold above asking

The larger one, close to 2,800 sq. ft., stalled around $1.6 million. Competition only pushes the price up where the buyers are.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 7/9
The seller's dilemma
08
Do the math before you list

Sell fast and you worry you priced too low. Sell slow and you think your agent is not trying. Plan first, so you do not regret it later.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 8/9
Your own home
09
Not sure how to price yours?

Tell Yifei where it is, how big it is and how many similar homes are listed nearby. He will tell you straight how he would price it.

Ask Yifei
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 9/9

Why not list high and negotiate?

List price isn't sale price; that's a common misconception. The number in your head is yours, not the buyer's.

Listing high causes two problems. First, buyers search by price range, so if you're priced well above market, the people who should see your home never find it. Second, the buyers who do come start low and work up slowly. Yifei's example: a home listed at around $700,000 got an offer in the $500,000s and ended up in the $600,000s, one step at a time.

That's why Yifei would rather tell a seller the truth up front, even when his estimate is lower than they hoped, than list high just to test the market.

Three ways to price

Strategy
List low, hold offers
HowBelow market, with a set offer date
Best forLots of buyers, few similar listings, such as smaller homes at popular price points
RiskIf nobody bids, you need to reprice fast
Price to market
HowAt or just under comparable sales
Best forMost homes
RiskSells quickly, and sellers wonder if they left money behind
List high, negotiate
HowWell above market, wait for offers
Best forRarely, unless the home is truly one of a kind
RiskFew showings, more days on market, a price cut later

How to set it

  1. Work out market value from recent sales of similar homes nearby. Ignore what you paid and what the house next door is asking.
  2. Watch price thresholds. Buyers search in round brackets, like under $2 million. If you're near one, list just under it to pull in that whole group, and let offers push the price up.
  3. If you're going for multiple offers, set the backup plan first: the offer date, the relist price if nobody bids, and your bottom line.
  4. When the first low offer comes in, do not sign it and do not reject it outright. Counter and see how they respond.

What Yifei has seen

Yifei listed two homes in Oakville with similar finishes, a natural side-by-side test. The smaller one, under 2,500 sq. ft., was listed noticeably lower than the larger one, drew several offers and sold above asking. The larger one, close to 2,800 sq. ft., was listed in the mid $1.6 millions, and the buyer stopped at around $1.6 million. The bigger home was the one that fell short of asking. The difference wasn't the house, it was how many buyers were shopping at that price: competition only pushes the price up where the buyers are.

Another home used both strategies. Yifei and the seller agreed to list in the $400,000s with a set offer date; if nobody bid, they'd relist right away at just over $500,000 and negotiate. The seller's bottom line was a little below that, and they left it to Yifei.

On a third, the top of the estimated value range was close to $1 million. Yifei advised against listing at the top and suggested going a few tens of thousands lower for a faster sale and a quicker closing.

Yifei also talks about the seller's dilemma: sell fast and you worry you priced too low; sell slow and you think your agent isn't trying. Doing the math before you list beats regretting it afterwards.

Frequently asked questions

If I list low and nobody bids, am I stuck with a low price?

No. Agree in advance that if no offers come in on offer night, you reprice. Yifei relists at market value right away and negotiates from there.

Why not list high to leave room to negotiate?

Yifei doesn't. Buyers who should see your home can't find it, and the ones who do start very low. The longer it sits, the weaker your position.

The first offer is really low. Should I reject it?

Do not reject it outright, and do not sign it either. Counter and see how they respond.

Want advice for your own home?

Location, size and how many similar homes are listed nearby all change the price. Listing high buys you time on the market, not room to negotiate. Tell me about your home and your situation, and I'll tell you straight how I'd price it. Yifei, RE/MAX, efay.ai.

Sources

Yifei on this topic (video in Mandarin)

卖房,为什么要列低价?只为了抢offer 吗?卖房挂低价并不是卖房的万能解药,一飞将详细根据不同的市场环境,不同房屋类型来跟您详细讲解卖房该怎样列定价! · YouTube 一飞说地产

Yifei Lin is a RE/MAX real estate agent serving the Greater Toronto Area and Niagara since 2015. For advice on your own situation, reach him at efay.ai.

All questions