Team YifeiTeam YifeiRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., BrokerageAsk Yifei · Real Estate Q&A中文

Selling in Ontario this winter: should I agree to a holdback so the buyer can fix the roof in spring?

Here's my honest take: if you can fix the roof before closing, fix it and send the buyer the invoice. Don't push the problem into spring. If you do agree to a holdback, the money goes into a lawyer's trust account and every term gets nailed down in writing. If the terms can't be nailed down, I'd rather you drop the price a little.
The 1 minute version
1 / 8
Ask Yifei · Closing
01
Buyer wants a roof holdback until spring. Should you agree?
Dec to Feb
when Ontario roofs sit under snow

Swipe for the 1 minute answer

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 1/8
Yifei's take
02
Fix it before closing if you can

Send the buyer the invoice. If you hold back money, it goes in a lawyer's trust account. Can't nail down the terms? Drop the price a little.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 2/8
Why it comes up in winter
03
Dec to Feb
Inspectors can't get on the roof

Reports say have a roofer assess. Many roofers won't reshingle in deep cold, so the work waits for spring.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 3/8
Your options
04
Four ways to go
01Price cut or creditOne clean deal, nothing after closing
02Fix before closingYour roofer, but maybe just a patch
03Holdback until springPrice holds, terms must be tight
04Say noBuyer may not firm up
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 4/8
Which one fits
05
Old roof, cut. Hidden roof, hold back.

If the roof is clearly old, a price cut is cleanest. If it's just under snow and you're confident, a holdback can work in your favour.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 5/8
If you agree
06
Put all of this in writing
  • 01Money in a lawyer's trust account
  • 02Amount based on written roofing quotes
  • 03Specific work, like shingles and flashing
  • 04Who hires, and a real deadline
  • 05Pay against invoice, balance to seller
  • 06Who covers overruns or unfinished work
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 6/8
What Yifei has seen
07
Neither side holds the money
  • 01Open work order? Money sits with the lawyer
  • 02Cleared in time goes to seller, otherwise buyer
  • 03Attic mould fixed, invoice sent before closing
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 7/8
Your own sale
08
Buyer asking for a holdback?

Tell Yifei about the roof, what the buyer asked for and where the conditions stand. He'll tell you straight what he'd do.

Ask Yifei
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 8/8

You can agree, as long as the money sits in a lawyer's trust account, not with the buyer and not with you. Put the amount, the exact work, who hires the roofer, the deadline, and who gets any leftover money in writing. If those terms can't be pinned down, a price reduction or fixing what you can before closing is usually cleaner.

Why this comes up in winter

From December to February, Ontario roofs are often under snow. Home inspectors can't get up there, so the report says something like "roof near end of life, have a roofer assess." Many roofers prefer not to reshingle in deep cold, saying the sealant strips don't bond well, so the work often waits for spring.

The buyer's worry is fair: if the roof leaks after closing, it's on them. The seller's worry is fair too: once money is held back, how much gets spent in spring isn't up to them.

Your options as the seller

Option
Lower the price or give a credit
UpsideOne clean deal, nothing after closing
Watch out forHave both lawyers check how a credit should be handled, including any lender requirements if the buyer has a mortgage
Fix it before closing
UpsideYou pick the roofer and control cost
Watch out forYou may only get a temporary patch in winter
Holdback until spring
UpsidePrice stays the same
Watch out forVague terms lead to fights in April
Say no
UpsideYou give up nothing
Watch out forThe buyer may not firm up

If the roof is clearly old and you were ready to drop a bit anyway, a price cut is the cleanest. If the roof is just hidden under snow and you're confident it's fine, a holdback can actually work in your favour.

What the holdback terms should cover

What Yifei has seen

On one deal, the city had an open work order on the house and closing was close. Yifei was worried the city would drag its feet, so the proposal was to hold a sum with the lawyer for a short window after closing: if the order was cleared in that time, the money went back to the seller; if not, it went to the buyer. That way the closing date didn't have to move, and neither side had to trust the other to hand the money back.

The roof works the same way: neither side holds the money, and the result on the deadline decides where it goes.

On another deal, the inspection found mould in the attic. Yifei and the seller agreed to have a professional remove it and send the invoice to the buyer before closing. That's cleaner than a holdback, because the issue is finished on closing day.

Yifei's advice

  1. Get a roofer out, even just to look from the ground, and get a written quote before negotiating.
  2. Have your lawyer draft the holdback clause. Agents shouldn't write legal terms.
  3. If the buyer has a mortgage, have the lawyers check whether the lender has any conditions.
  4. Fix what you can before closing so fewer things are left for spring.

Frequently asked questions

Who should hold the holdback money?

Usually a lawyer, in trust, not the buyer or the seller. The two lawyers agree on which office holds it and put that in the amendment.

What if the roof costs more than the holdback?

It depends on the wording. If the clause doesn't say who pays the overrun, expect a dispute, so settle it before signing.

If I refuse, will the buyer walk?

They might, if their inspection condition isn't waived yet, depending on how the condition is worded; if you're unsure, ask your lawyer. Weigh the cost of losing this buyer against the cost of holding back some money.

Tell me about your situation and I'll tell you straight what I'd do (Yifei, RE/MAX, efay.ai).

Sources

Yifei Lin is a RE/MAX real estate agent serving the Greater Toronto Area and Niagara since 2015. For advice on your own situation, reach him at efay.ai.

All questions