Team YifeiTeam YifeiRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., BrokerageAsk Yifei · Real Estate Q&A中文

I bought a pre-construction home in Niagara. Can I sell it before closing?

Here's my honest take: you can often assign a pre-construction home, but don't treat an assignment as your exit plan. People assume they can sell any time before closing if they change their mind. In reality, whether you can assign, when, and whether you can list it publicly are all written into your agreement with the builder. This is for anyone in Niagara who bought pre-construction and wants out before closing. Many builders require written consent and charge an assignment fee, and some contracts restrict when you can assign or ban listing it on MLS. Assignment sales of new homes are generally subject to HST, so ask an accountant how the profit will be taxed before you go ahead.
The 1 minute version
1 / 9
Ask Yifei · Pre-construction
01
Bought pre-construction in Niagara. Can I sell before closing?
20%
in deposits, paid long before closing

Swipe for the 1 minute answer

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 1/9
Yifei's take
02
You can often assign. It's not an exit plan.

Whether you can assign, when, and whether you can list publicly are all set by your agreement with the builder.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 2/9
Why you can't just sell
03
Before closing, you own a contract

In an assignment, someone takes your place and finishes the purchase, so the builder gets a say. After closing, it's a regular resale.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 3/9
Check your agreement
04
Look for these clauses
01Assignment clauseAllowed, allowed with conditions, or not at all
02Assignment feeHow much, and who pays legal costs
03MLS allowed?Some builders only allow private assignments
04When you can assignMaybe not until the builder sells out
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 4/9
How the money works
05
Run the numbers first
  • 01Deposit paid plus any amount above your price
  • 02Builder fee as set in your contract
  • 03HST generally applies, so ask an accountant
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 5/9
If you're underwater
06
The price can come in below yours

Pre-construction has been tough lately. If you're underwater, decide: assign at a loss, or come up with the money and close.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 6/9
Condo buyers, take note
07
2 dates
Occupancy first, final closing later

You get keys at interim occupancy. The balance and mortgage start at final closing, once the building is registered.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 7/9
What Yifei has seen
08
$500K+
still due on closing day

A client paid close to 20% in deposits early. The rest was due at final closing, and the mortgage amount hinged on the appraisal.

Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 8/9
Your own situation
09
Can you assign your unit?

Tell Yifei what your contract says and how far along construction is. He'll tell you straight what to do.

Ask Yifei
Yifei Lin, Sales RepresentativeRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
efay.ai · 9/9

Why you can't just sell it

Before closing, the home isn't yours yet. What you own is a contract. In an assignment, someone takes your place in that contract and finishes the purchase from the builder. The builder is the other party, so it gets a say in who that is.

After closing, it's different. Once title is in your name, selling is a regular resale and the builder has nothing to do with it.

What to look for in your agreement

Every builder's paperwork is different. Have a lawyer read it before you sign and again before you assign.

How the money works

Item
From the new buyer
What it meansThe deposit you've paid, plus any amount above your original price
To the builder
What it meansThe assignment fee in your contract
Agent
What it meansYou'll usually need one to find a buyer; commission as agreed
Lawyer
What it meansAn assignment needs proper legal paperwork
Tax
What it meansAssignments of new homes are generally subject to HST; ask an accountant how the profit and HST work

The assignment price can also come in below your original contract price. Yifei's take is that pre-construction has been a tough market these past couple of years, and many agents who built their business on it have moved to resale. If you're underwater, you need to run the numbers: assign at a loss, or come up with the money and close.

Condos have two dates

A pre-construction condo usually has an interim occupancy date, when you get the keys and can move in before title transfers, and later a final closing once the building is registered. That's when the balance is due and the mortgage starts. Freehold towns and detached homes usually have a single closing date. If you plan to assign, find out exactly how late your contract lets you do it.

What Yifei has seen

Recently, a client bought a pre-construction condo for their daughter. The price was around $700,000 including HST, and they'd paid close to 20% in deposits over time, with a little over $500,000 still due on closing. Getting the keys wasn't final closing yet. The mortgage was approved, but the amount still depended on the appraisal. The deposit goes in early, and the balance and financing aren't settled until the last day. That's why the first thing I work out with pre-construction buyers is this: if you can't assign it, can you close it yourself? My job is to turn the risks you haven't thought of into risks you've planned for, not to tell you the assignment will be fine.

Another seller had bought a condo from the builder years earlier and only called Yifei after it had closed. At that point it was an ordinary resale, with no builder consent needed.

Frequently asked questions

Does the builder have to approve an assignment?

Many agreements require written consent, and some don't allow assignments at all. Your own contract decides; have a lawyer review it.

Can I list an assignment on MLS?

It depends on the agreement. Some builders don't allow public listings, only private sales.

Is assignment profit taxable?

It has to be reported. The CRA says assignment sales of newly built homes are generally subject to GST/HST. Leave the calculation to your accountant.

Want advice for your own situation?

Your contract, how far along construction is and what the unit is worth today all change the answer. An assignment is a door your contract opens, not a back exit before closing. Tell me your situation and I'll tell you straight what to do: Yifei (RE/MAX), efay.ai.

Sources

Yifei on this topic (video in Mandarin)

房地产投资,到底应该买楼花还是二手房?到底哪个的收益比较多?在楼花交接提前转让可不可行?二手房和楼花的投资利弊又有哪些?一飞今天详细对比一下二手房和楼花的投资收益! · YouTube 一飞说地产

Yifei Lin is a RE/MAX real estate agent serving the Greater Toronto Area and Niagara since 2015. For advice on your own situation, reach him at efay.ai.

All questions